Tariq Hameed Karra raises possible mistaken-identity angle; BJP rejects claim and points to missing weapons, suspected militant involvement
Avinash Azad
The deaths of two Special Police Officers in the remote Dachhan area of Kishtwar have sparked a political confrontation in Jammu and Kashmir, with the Congress demanding an impartial investigation into all possible angles and the BJP rejecting suggestions that the personnel may have been killed in a case of mistaken identity.
The bullet-hit bodies of Babi Chand, 57, and Rashpal Kumar, 45, both residents of Kiyar village, were recovered on November 12, a day after they went missing in the forested Dachhan-Marwah belt. Reports said their service weapons were missing, while security forces launched an extensive operation to identify and apprehend those responsible.
Police and security officials reportedly believe the two SPOs were travelling towards an Army post at Dharna-Marwah to relieve personnel when they were attacked. No militant organisation had publicly claimed responsibility at the time of the initial reports.
Jammu and Kashmir Congress president Tariq Hameed Karra said the central question was how the two officers died and called for every possible explanation to be investigated.
Citing information attributed to his party’s district president, Karra said one account suggested that the SPOs had gone hunting in civilian clothes and crossed two Army check-posts without being stopped. He claimed that, while returning, they may have encountered a different patrol that mistook them for militants and opened fire.
Karra presented this as a theory requiring investigation rather than an established finding. He contrasted it with the BJP’s position that militants were responsible and said only a credible inquiry could establish the facts.
The Congress leader also accused the BJP of attempting to communalise the incident. He questioned Kishtwar BJP MLA Shagun Parihar’s allegation that announcements threatening Hindus had been made from mosques, saying such a serious claim must be supported by evidence.
Jammu and Kashmir Leader of the Opposition and BJP leader Sunil Sharma strongly rejected Karra’s account. He said Babi Chand and Rashpal Kumar were attached to the Special Operations Group and were travelling on official duty towards an Army position, not on a hunting trip.
Sharma argued that the disappearance of the SPOs’ rifles, magazines and ammunition supported the suspected militant-attack theory. He also cited reports of armour-piercing cartridges recovered from the area and the police decision to issue posters for three wanted militants, with a combined reward of Rs 30 lakh.
The BJP leader accused Karra of making an unverified allegation against the Army and demanded that he withdraw the statement and apologise to the families and security forces.
BJP spokesperson Altaf Thakur separately alleged that Karra’s remarks cast unsupported aspersions on the professionalism of the security forces and could damage their morale.
While attributing the deaths to militants, Sharma also raised questions about operational planning. He asked why two SPOs had allegedly been sent alone through a militancy-affected forest and why one was reportedly equipped with an older .303 rifle.
Parihar’s allegation concerning announcements from a mosque was challenged from within the BJP itself. Kishtwar BJP leader Jahanzaib Sirwal described the claim as factually unsubstantiated and warned against linking religious institutions to provocative activity without credible evidence. The Islami Markaz-e-Majlis Shura Kishtwar, headed by Jamia Masjid Imam Maulana Farooq Ahmad Kichloo, also rejected the allegation as baseless and demanded a public apology, warning that unverified claims could disturb communal harmony.




